DISCREPANCIES IN SCREENING BY SCREENER AND SCREENING THRU WATCHLIST

DISCREPANCIES IN SCREENING BY SCREENER AND SCREENING THRU WATCHLIST

felik
2010-05-22 15:06:32

Why
is it that results of screening with screener andTHRU watch list are
different even though i used the same rule i.e. close >
1.02*sma(200). Watchlist returned only 3 results BOI HINDALO AND JSW
STEEL. WHEREAS SCREENER RETURNED MANY??? and that too of these many stocks there are a no of stocks which do not qualify the screener condition one example is bank of maharashtra its 200sma is 48.8 and close is 54.2 thats way above 2% its just one example infact there are many such examples mahindara life is not shown in EITHER SCREENING (WATCH LIST AND SCREENER )WHEREAS ITS 200SMA IS 377AND CLOSE IS 406 SO ITS MORE THEN 2% AS MENTIONED IN SCREENER THEN HOW COME IT WAS EXCLUDED IN EITHER SCREENING????? GLENMARK AS EXCLUDED CANT FIGURE OUT WHY THESE DISCREPANCIES.? MAY BE A BUG OR 2 STILL PRESENT????????????????
I HOPE THESE DISCREPANCIES WILL BE LOOKED IN TO PROMPTLY AS USUAL.

QuantShare
2010-05-24 06:24:04

I have tested the "close > 1.02*sma(200)" rule on both screener and watchlist and get exactly the same results. 679 stocks as of 21/05/2010.
Make sure that you have specified the same settings. In watchlist, set the "Display symbols that pass the rules" option to "for the last: one day".

The 200-bar SMA of Bank of Maharashtra is 48.8 and its close price is 54.2 and therefore the "close > 1.02*sma(200)" is True.
There are no bugs or discrepancies between the watchlist and screener plugins.

felik
2010-05-24 07:33:43

thanks for the guidence and clarification

Get more messages

No more messages

Back


Trading Items Buy signal watchlist And Buy signal on your Chart (Red Spot) Head and Shoulders Pattern Covered Call Screener Covered Put Screener Recent mergers and acquisitions	How-to Lessons Difference between the watchlist and the screener tools How to speed up watchlist and screener plug-ins when working with... How to run a screen or a watchlist from a script How to drag & drop a stock to a static watchlist How to create a watchlist
Related Forum Threads wrong screening in cdl patterns BUG IN CDL SCREENING Access all the elements of a custom db during screening indicator for 1 symbol in screener and simulation Screening for consolidation after large price/vol gain	Blog Posts Screening with the composite indicators Backtesting chart patterns using the auto support and resistance ... How to speed up quotes and news downloads How to use QuantShare screener to trade penny stocks Inverse Fisher Transform: Indicator, composite and trading system